Thursday, October 22, 2026, David J. Kahn

OMg, what a clever puzzle today. I didn't really notice the asterisks on some clues until I reached the third one and realized I was leaving a lot of white space behind me. I switched to the Downs and then hopscotched around, ending with almost the whole right side empty, including the revealer, because there was so much I didn't know in the lower right corner, I didn't know the "Region that produces Riesling wine" (SAAR), and I couldn't immediately figure out the ambiguous "First out" (ORIGINAL), not to mention the one mis-matchbox for this solver, "Item in a miniature collector's collection" (MODELCAR). I fancy myself something of a miniature collector and I don't have a single model car, so it took me a while to come up with that one. Also, as our dear Readers know, I am always at something of a loss when it comes to sports clues ("Team with the most Super Bowl wins in the 1970s" (STEELERS) :(). However, even when I did finally get the revealer ("'Forget it!' ... or a phonetic hint to aligning seven answers in this puzzle with their starred clues") I didn't get it. I ended up solving the entire puzzle without knowing why "*Trendy" was ALAMODOME or "*Subs" was HOMEROOMS. I closed the puzzle, and closed my eyes. Not looking at the spelling of the revealer answer helped me with the phonetic element because, about ten minutes later, the solution came to me. One needs to read NOCHANCE as "no chants," which, as far as the theme answers are concerned indicates that one needs to remove the OMs from each to get an answer that matches the clue. So, for the two mentioned above, the "real" or aligned answers are ALAMODE and HEROS, the latter containing two chantses being especially cool. Additionally excellent that the answers with the OMs make completely legitimate entries. And, plus, too, I loved the careful and accurate description of the revealer. It tells you what you need to know without giving it away. 

My one aforementioned non-matchbox not withstanding, there were a bunch of clues where my first guess was the right answer. I mention it not because that makes me a good puzzle solver but because I felt I was on the right wavelength for once. In particular, I enjoyed "Something passed at a charity event" for HAT, NIT for "Small grouse," and "Display, with 'out'" (TROT).

Also fun were the several mini puzzles within the puzzle like "What makes her hear?" (ANA [the letter A]), - ha! - "Island capital that's an anagram for a word meaning 'steamy baths'" (NASSAU [saunas]), and the QMC "Tops of palaces?" (TIARAS). 

Only a few clue/answer pairs HANOI'd me, to wit "Nursery cry" (WAH), HIRER for "ZipRecruiter client," and IMPISH for "Bratty," the former being possibly cute or funny, the latter never so, but maybe that's me.

I'm not sure I've done the puzzle justice with this rambling review, but I thought it was great and great fun.

~Frannie.

Wednesday, October 21, 2026, Rebecca Goldstein

One could describe today's theme answers as descriptive report card entries. The idea is to replace the class name and letter grade in the clue with a common two-word phrase that expresses an equivalent idea. For example,"Driver's Ed: B" is lined up with PARKINGFINE. I give the idea itself high marks, but for this solver, both PARKINGFINE and especially MOVINGAVERAGE ("Gym: B+"), are not such common phrases. When I am the perpetrator of malparkage, I usually get a ticket, not a parking fine. And I'm not even sure what a MOVINGAVERAGE is. And furthermore, is a B+ average? I would have thought that would be a C, but I am old and largely out of touch with modern life. Although, come to think of it, I have heard tell of grade inflation at universities in the past year, so maybe that explains it. The third theme answer, BUILDINGSUPER ("Wood shop: A"), is quite good, but they saved the best for last with PASTPERFECT ("History: A+). 

Several other answers over the course of the puzzle played a little off to me. For example, we always called a "Teacher's pet, say, in slang" a suckUP, not a KISSUP, but maybe you can put "suck" in an NYT puzzle, or, maybe it's just a regional/temporal variation. Also, the adjective ACED for "Like a tennis player who didn't even swing, maybe" seemed awkward, "Mono-" for UNI was utilitarian, and the "Nutrition sources" for DIETS, uninspired. I also thought that LAIDBARE was a bit extreme for its clue "Made public." Again, I plead my ERA. 

On the plus side, "Tender bend-er" for BUMKNEE was amusing, "First and last" for FULLNAME was nicely ambiguous and "Alt tab?" for LSD was excellent. KNOTTY, KAPUT, and TOUGHNUT were fun fill. To sum up, I  had a little bit of a tassel at commencement, but I also applaud the diploma-tic effort.

~Frannie.

Tuesday, October 20, 2026, David Falkowski

ALLKIDDINGASIDE is literally what we find in the four theme answers WEENIEROAST, SLEIGHRIDE, BRUISEDRIB, SPACENEEDLE. The second word in each (ROAST, RIDE, RIB, NEEDLE) appears to the right side of the two-word nouns. All four, in this context, evoke an element of discomfort, although only "roast" and "needle" carry that element with them intrinsically. Even after I got the revealer, I didn't really get the theme answers until the grid was complete. Also, WEENIEROAST turned out to be my bête noire as I didn't know "Gymnast Suni" LEE, and spelled "weenie" with an interior EI. ERR. 

Other TRIALS for this solver turned out to be ECIG for "Device with an addictive aerosol, for short." Apparently, I don't know much about ecigs. I also struggled to find the parallel between the clue "Laid back" and the answer ATEASE, reading it as a personality trait rather than a position description. I found the correspondence between the clue "Appears to be going down the drain" and the answer SEEMSBAD to be LAX. And, the final issue I'll RAISE is the C/AP "Piece of goalie gear" for LEGPAD, which left me cold. :)

What helped pick up the PACE, though, were clue/answer pairs like "Flattering lines?" for ODE, "Loud speaker, maybe" (ORATOR), "Overlook" for LEDGE, and the fun-to-spell out ROLAIDS, of days gone by ("One way to spell relief, per ads"). FLAY, at 22A, describes some pretty harsh criticism, although, it also makes me think of the hilarious Simpson's Itchy & Scratchy episode, "Flay me to the Moon." Heh. 

~Frannie.

Monday, October 19, 2026, Michele Govier

Today, the SUN, from its place in the top left corner of the puzzle, shines down on three items, an AWNING, a TREE, and a HAT, creating SHADOWBOXES, one row below and one square to the right, that contain "shadows" of the items above within a longer answer: FAWNINGOVER ("Giving excessive praise and flattery"), STREETWEAR ("Urban casual fashion"), and THATSRIGHT ("'You are correct'"). Looking at the grid just now, I thought another approach that might have been cool would be to have corresponding black squares appear under each of the shade-generating items, but maybe that would just be throwing shade.

Overall, the puzzle was a mix of light and dark. Bright spots include the SUN, obviously :), the Question Mark Clue "Made some waves?" (PERMED), and "Floats in the breeze" (WAFTS) - not to mention some fun fill like SERENE, NEAPOLITAN, and the always entertaining OAF. 

OTOH, I thought it played on the easy side, even for a Monday, with an array of gimmes like "Clear, as a chalkboard" for ERASE, "Uses oars" for ROWS, "Month with Mother's Day" (MAY), and, my least favorite kind of clue/answer pair, "180° from SSE" for NNW, where I feel like the clue is equivalent to "enter these letters." Also, what's the deal with SINEW muscling in on every grid of late? Is that a trend, or mere coincidence? I WANDA.

~Frannie.

Sunday, October 18, 2026, Peter Gorman

TELL ME ABOUT YOURSELF

This was a tough one for me. I understood most of the rebus-y clues for the theme answers only after I solved them. IMABITCONFUSED (Taib? Tbia?) was an understatement! But ITELLYOUWHAT ("What") was my favorite. That's beautiful.

In addition to the theme answers, there were some very clever clues in this one. QMCs "Extended play?" (ENCORE) and "Undercover?" (ABED) were cute, but the real stars were the non-QMCs. "It turns when driven" (SCREW), "Drill" (REHEARSAL), "Smash hit" (HOMER), "They can make a pronounced difference" (UMLAUTS), and "Something in which you might stand for a spell" (BEE) were all very good. And where else but in a crossword can you find OVID rubbing shoulders with Bob ROSS, and Teresa of AVILA standing beside the VEDAS (Sacred Sanskrit texts). 

It was a challenge, but a satisfying one. I hope you enjoyed it too.

Frannie takes over tomorrow, so stay tuned for that! And I'll see you again in a few weeks.

- Horace 

Saturday, October 17, 2026, August Miller

0:22:48

Whoosh! It started well up in the NE when CRANES (Birds whose wings might be folded) (Cute), HELIO (Prefix with -trope), and other Downs made CHEFSTABLE (Award-winning culinary documentary series), and RECIPEBOOK (Where some family secrets may be written) come into focus. And I like to think that the editors were hoping that PAINTJOB (Part of many home improvement projects) would align with the timeline of a certain bathroom renovation that I was talking about a while ago, but no, sadly, it's not there yet thank you very little.

So anyway, then it got tough. I was wondering how I missed the story about the phenomenal athlete who was "Gold medalist in women's soccer and women's team foil (fencing) at 2024's Olympics, in brief," but it wasn't a single person, it was THEUS. It was just one of many general answers today - TECHCEO, CASHAPP, BEERBARS, and SEDERPLATE, to name four.

Elsewhere, I racked my brain trying to remember the section of the Boy Scouts manual that dealt with "Poison classification," but no, it was a different thing entirely - HAIRMETAL. Hah! And I was also misled by "Tie with string." I wanted so many different verbs, never thinking of a noun until BOLO was forced on me, and even then it took a second to realize they were talking about neckwear. 

We love a good challenge on a Saturday, and this certainly fit the bill!

- Horace 

Friday, October 16, 2026, Adam Shapiro

0:13:20

A wide-open Friday with four fifteens and two thirteens, lots of seven-letter Downs. The black squares make regular and upside-down smiley faces, and they worked in kind of an opposite way for me. I was slow to get a footing in the top, while the bottom went more smoothly.

Where to begin? How about with Britney, and her "2000 hit song with the lyric 'But to lose all my senses / That is just so typically me'" (OOPSIDIDITAGAIN). This is the fifth time that classic has appeared in a NYT crossword. Its stackmate EPISTOLARYNOVEL is appearing for the first time. When I think of such novels, the one that always leaps to mind is "Possession" by A.S. Byatt. I'm not even entirely sure that that book is an EPISTOLARYNOVEL, but letters do factor into it. 

Hey, you know what also fits for the clue "Reality show whose contestants report to the Judge's Table? "Bake Off." Of course, that's not the official name of that show, so TOPCHEF it is.  

Tricky clues abounded: "Flow down the neck" for MANE, "Hot pockets?" for RAVIOLI, "Small sounds" for INLETS, and the very odd "20-20, e.g." for TIEVOTE. And is it okay to have the clues "Rocky openings?" (YOS) and "Indiana Jones or Rocky Balboa, e.g." (ALLAMERICANHERO)? 

 This wasn't exactly smooth, but it was a good Friday challenge. What did you think of it?

- Horace