Saturday, May 27, 2017

Saturday, May 27, 2017, Damon Gulczinski

11:57

I couldn't believe I had COLPORTEUR correct, but all the crosses worked. Happily, when I filled in my final square at the crossing of EGAN and ASSN, I got the happy little tune. Clearly it comes from French, where it apparently means a peddler, and then got associated with religious literature. Definitely a new word for me.

Melbourne is in Florida, apparently, not Australia. That fooled me for a while. I enjoyed all three long across answers, but should the clue have had a "familiarly" attached to it for FLORIDATECH? The full name is Florida Institute of Technology. Not that that bothered me. I wouldn't have gotten it without most of the crosses. Meanwhile, FLEXITARIAN is lovely, and PALEBLUEDOT is of course, excellent.

DONTTHATBEATALL? I'd say. I love that phrase, and it's a wonderful 15-letter crossing answer.

The rest of the puzzle has some nice high points. 10D: Be subtly and snarkily insulting (THROWSHADE) is great and contemporary. EGOSURF has been seen a number of times by now in the puzzle, so it's a little less sparkling.

DIETETICS and ANTENATAL are all right. I don't know why it took me so long to figure out the latter.

1A: Honor in a big way (FETE) - C. Nothing special to start a Saturday.
Fave: CHARY (16A: Word that's its own synonym when its first two letters are replaced with "w") - such an involved clue! It also reminds me G&S, namely Iolanthe:

A plague on this vagary
I'm in a nice quandary
Of hasty tones
With dames unknown
I ought to be more chary...

Least fave: ASSN (20A: N.E.A. member?: Abbr.). Yeah. Abbreviated answer from an abbreviation, not improved much by the slightly clever clue.

I'm not sure if the puzzle is quite TOPSHELF, but I enjoyed it over all.

- Colum

5 comments:

  1. 37:50
    I had TOPNOTCH instead of TOPSHELF.
    Also, the CHARY clue threw me because for some reason I thought both of the first two letters got replaced with W.
    The rest went pretty smoothly, so not sure why it took 40 minutes but here we are.

    ReplyDelete
  2. 40:55
    I probably wasted a good 10 minutes in the SW trying to remember Jim Abbott's name. In my defense, it was the Yankees and, thus, I take some solace for the mental block. But even so, it was a heck of story and I do remember that mild thaw 24 years ago in my Red Sox heart when it happened.

    Also, sports: I take issue with 60A: "One of two areas in a football line." Yes, the majority of offensive formations have two slots. But the way the clue is written it implies a categorical; like, two sets of goal posts, two end zones, 11 men on a side, etc. There is no rule requiring two slots. Field goal and punt formations have zero slots. Typical goal line and short yardage formations have no slots. Run-heavy offensives, including Ys and wildcats often stack the line and eschew wide receives in favor of, for example, double tight ends. The rule requires "at least 7 players on the line of scrimmage" and that can be either spread out with slots or tight without them.

    Also, while I'm at it, did anyone else dislike BOATS (48A: One making bank-to-bank transfers?)? Maybe the "?" in this case saves it, but BOATS is pretty generic for ferries and cargo ships.

    ReplyDelete
  3. 32:56
    Well, Icarus, a bit too much explanation of the sports there for old Huygens, but that's OK. I will agree with you on BOAT. I wanted "eddy" or something certainly a bit more elegant for a Saturday. I've never heard of a FLEXITARIAN and will never make use of the term in any conversation. PALEBLUEDOT, and the Great Carl Sagan, are fantastic (did I mention I own three original paintings by the principal Cosmos artist?). I loved the clue for ANNOTATE (39A Gloss); that took a while to get, especially with BOER, ABBOT and COLPORTEUR in that corner. Fave? BOSOMY, of course!

    ReplyDelete
  4. 30:45
    The SW was my undoing as well. I did, eventually, think of ABBOTT, but I had entered "closer" in 41D (Like Mars vis-a-vis Jupiter (NEARER)) and was loath to take it out. It didn't help that I guessed POLO for the "Great Trek figure," ignoring the fact that the date was five or six hundred years off. Sheesh! Anyway, I enjoyed much of this, despite my difficulties.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I was amazed to pull ABBOTT immediately out of my memory upon seeing the clue. I used to read all sorts of books about unusual things that had happened in the history of baseball.

      Delete