I love the theme today! I guess I’ve always been the kind of
person who enjoys challenging standards and pushing at boundaries and
restrictions. So when I come across a puzzle that so obviously breaks the
established norms by having nine words appear twice in the grid, I am delighted. The
justification here (and there always should be some justification - I don't suggest anarchy!) is that when you encounter each word a second time, the word
“second” is implied. As in 55A: What you will always be (but he or she isn’t)?
(PERSON). That’s “second person,”
grammatically. Excellent.
They’re all perfectly “in the language,” and somehow each of
them surprised me a little bit. It’s lucky Frannie was sitting beside me on the
couch, and we were solving together, so she could explain it over and over
again. :)
Aside from the excellent theme, there were some additional
bonus elements. I very much enjoyed the clues for HOTTUB “Somewhere to chill, paradoxically” (Clever!), BERRA (“If you can’t imitate him, don’t
copy him” speaker) (He never disappoints), and the first NATURE (“All ____ is but art, unknown to thee”: Alexander Pope).
“Indication of good taste?” (YUM), “Couple of high points?” (UMLAUT), and “Shell station?” (SEASHORE)
were three cute QMCs. And if I weren’t on the SEASHORE myself right now, where
the Internet connection is not at all reliable, I would try to find out why a BANANA is slightly radioactive! Is it
bad that I eat one every day?!?
And maybe it’s all that radioactive fruit I’ve been eating,
but I am not sure I understand TDS (Bear
necessities, for short?). I guess they must mean the Chicago Bears, a football
team, but somehow putting it into the singular just seems a little too far to
go.
But that aside, I still call for a LAUREL for Misters Liben-Nowell and Barocas. They’re both real SMARTIES in my book.
- Horace
Me too, me too! Loved it! I had several pairs into the grid before noticing them...and it was that "second" PERSON entry that tipped me off! AHA!
ReplyDeleteI did have a spot of trouble with "TUNaS" in the uppper NE - could have been some sort of fish terms with which I was unfamiliar...
And since I live right beside my computer, I'll tell you a bit about bananas - they have a naturally occurring radioactive potassium isotope. It is noncumulative in the body. Someone, circa 1995, came up with a measurement for such things - called Banana equivalent dose (BED). The Wiki article is pretty cool for any one who want more deets!
Thanks for the review.
~MLou
Thanks for the banana info. I'm relieved! :)
DeleteFun puzzle, to be sure. I was so confused when I started seeing repeated answers in the puzzle. I finally figured it out with [second] NATURE. I too have a problem with the clue for TDS. And I messed up with putting in UTEp instead of UTES, so that was a FWOE. But otherwise a fun Sunday, and that's saying something!
ReplyDeleteI loved solving this puzzle! A perfect way to enjoy a relaxing Sunday afternoon...which is all I ask from the NYT Crossword Puzzle team!
ReplyDeleteHi Kelly! Thanks for checking in on us and leaving a comment! Glad to hear you also liked this one, and that you had what sounds like a lovely afternoon. :)
DeleteIt was terrific, Horace...thank YOU for the wonderful blog!
Delete49:03 (on paper)
ReplyDeleteI didn't know what was going on when it became obvious that there were two STRINGs side-by-side, but I eventually figured it out. Great how something like this gets IDEATED by a PERSON. I wanted steAlING where PIRATING goes, so that slowed me down a bit in the NE, and I tried soNgS where TUNES goes, but overall, I didn't have many problems. I think a more appropriate clue for HEDGEHOG would've been "Spiny Norman."